The Ultimate Avocado Mattress Comparison: Which Organic Bed is Your Perfect Match?

Tossing and turning, worried about the materials you’re sleeping on for a third of your life?

You’re not alone. The search for a non-toxic, eco-friendly mattress can be overwhelming.

You’ve likely heard the buzz about Avocado Green Mattress, a brand synonymous with organic and sustainable sleep.

But with several models and strong competitors, how do you know which one is truly right for you?

This comprehensive comparison is here to guide you. We’ll break down the key differences between Avocado’s popular mattresses and see how they stack up against other leading organic brands.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of each option and feel confident in your decision.

Avocado Mattress Comparison — Luxurious organic mattress

Understanding the Avocado Difference: What Makes Them a Top Choice?

Before diving into the models, let’s establish what makes Avocado a standout choice.

At their core, Avocado mattresses are latex hybrids, combining the support of innersprings with the comfort and durability of natural latex.

Latex foam is known to be more durable than polyurethane and memory foams.

They are renowned for their commitment to certified organic materials, holding some of the most rigorous certifications for health and sustainability.

In fact, the Avocado Green Mattress has been named the highest-rated innerspring mattress by Consumer Reports in March 2025.

This focus on organic and natural materials means you’re getting a mattress free from harmful chemicals, something that’s increasingly important to health-conscious consumers.

It also means their mattresses are known for their breathability and temperature regulation, making them a great option for hot sleepers.

Avocado Green Mattress: The Flagship, All-Around Performer

The Avocado Green Mattress is the brand’s most popular and well-known model, and for good reason—it’s a versatile crowd-pleaser.

Materials: It features GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex, GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton. The wool acts as a natural fire barrier and helps regulate temperature. Its construction includes zoned coils to provide more robust support where it’s needed most.
Firmness & Feel: The standard model is considered “firm” (about a 7 out of 10), which is ideal for back and stomach sleepers who need robust support to keep their spine aligned. For those desiring a softer feel, there are two upgrade options: a “medium” with a pillow-top and a “plush” with a box-top. The medium option is often recommended for combination and side sleepers.
Best For:
- Back and stomach sleepers (standard firm model).
- Side and combination sleepers (pillow-top or box-top models).
- Those seeking a balance of support and contouring.
- Eco-conscious shoppers who want a proven, popular option with a 1-year sleep trial and 25-year warranty.

Avocado Eco Organic Mattress: The Budget-Friendly Choice

For those who want the Avocado quality at a more accessible price point, the Eco Organic Mattress is the answer. It’s the brand’s entry-level model without compromising on core organic principles.

Materials: Like the Green Mattress, it’s made with GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool, and GOLS-certified organic latex.
Firmness & Feel: It comes in a single firmness option, a medium-firm (around a 7 out of 10), similar to the standard Green Mattress. However, some reviewers note it can feel slightly firmer to some and you’ll feel more “on top” of this mattress.
Key Differences from the Green Mattress:
- It is more affordable.
- It has a thinner profile and fewer coils (932 vs. 1,459 in a queen).
- It lacks the zoned support of the Green Mattress.
- It comes with a shorter 100-night trial period and a 10-year warranty.
Best For:
- Back and stomach sleepers who prefer a firm and lifted feel.
- Budget-conscious shoppers seeking an organic mattress.
- Hot sleepers will appreciate the breathable components of this latex hybrid design.

Avocado Luxury Organic Mattress: The Premium, Plush Option

As the name suggests, the Luxury Organic is Avocado’s most high-end mattress, designed for ultimate comfort and pressure relief.

Materials: It boasts up to 17 premium layers of materials, including organic cotton, hemp, silk, wool, and latex.
Firmness & Feel: This is Avocado’s softest line, available in “medium,” “plush,” and “ultra-plush.” Even the medium is softer than the Green Mattress with a pillow-top. The feel is responsive and buoyant, offering significant cushioning.
Best For:
- Side sleepers who need deep pressure relief for their hips and shoulders.
- Those who prefer a plusher, more luxurious feel.
- Shoppers looking for the most premium, handcrafted option.

Avocado Vegan Mattress: The Wool-Free Alternative

For those who avoid all animal products, the Avocado Vegan Mattress offers a high-quality, wool-free option.

Materials: It has a similar construction to the Green Mattress but replaces the organic wool with GOTS-certified organic cotton. It is certified by Vegan Action.
Firmness & Feel: It comes in a standard “gentle, yet firm” feel (a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale), with the option to add a pillow-top for a softer feel (a 6 out of 10).
Best For:
- Vegans or those who wish to avoid wool.
- Back and stomach sleepers (standard model).
- Shoppers who want the quality of the Green Mattress without animal-derived materials.

Avocado vs The Competition: How Do They Stack Up?

Feature	Avocado Green	Awara Premier Luxury Hybrid	Birch Natural
Firmness	Firm (7/10), Medium (6/10) with pillow-top, Medium (5/10) with box-top	Medium-Firm (6/10)	Medium-Firm (6/10)
Feel	Responsive and durable Dunlop latex	Bouncy and breathable Dunlop latex	Bouncy and pressure-relieving Talalay latex
Cooling	Excellent, sleeps slightly cooler than Awara	Excellent for hot sleepers	Very breathable
Key Advantage	Highly-rated, multiple firmness options, zoned support	More affordable, lifetime warranty	Enhanced edge support
Sleep Trial	365 nights	365 nights	100 nights
Warranty	25-Year Limited	Lifetime Limited	25-Year

Table data sourced from Sleep Foundation and Mattress Nerd.

Expert Tips for Success: Choosing Your Organic Mattress

Consider Your Sleep Position: This is the most crucial factor. Side sleepers generally need a softer mattress for pressure relief (Avocado Luxury or Green with a pillow-top), while back and stomach sleepers need a firmer surface for support (standard Avocado Green, Eco Organic, or Awara).
Factor in Your Body Weight: Heavier individuals (over 230 pounds) may find they need a firmer option with robust coil support like the standard Avocado Green for adequate support. Lighter individuals (under 130 pounds) might prefer the softer options to experience proper contouring.
Don’t Forget a Trial Period: Avocado offers a generous 1-year sleep trial for most of their mattresses, giving you ample time to ensure it’s the right fit. The Eco Organic has a 100-night trial.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Was there a lawsuit against Avocado Mattress?
Yes, a class-action lawsuit was filed in April 2023, alleging that Avocado mattresses contained synthetic chemicals, contrary to their “natural” and “organic” marketing.

However, the lawsuit was dismissed in August 2023.

While the plaintiffs’ attorneys believed the case had merit based on their own lab testing, Avocado maintained the claims were “baseless.”

Some legal analysts suggest the case may have been settled out of court.

2. Are there many complaints about Avocado mattresses?
Like any popular product, you can find some user complaints online.

Some Reddit users have mentioned concerns about sagging over time, while others have found the mattresses to be either too firm or too soft for their liking.

However, Avocado generally receives strong reviews from customers and media publications for their materials and customer service.

3. Can I buy an Avocado mattress at Costco?
Yes, Costco carries a specific model, the Avocado Organic 11″ Hybrid Mattress.

It’s important to note that models sold at retailers like Costco can sometimes differ slightly from those sold directly by the brand.

Some users have found the purchasing and return process to be straightforward through Costco.

4. Where can I find the best price or a discount code?
Avocado offers various discounts throughout the year.

You can often find promotions for a percentage off, especially on mattress protectors and pillows.

They also offer discounts for military personnel, teachers, students, and healthcare professionals.

Signing up for their newsletter may also provide you with an initial discount.

Your Next Steps to Better Sleep

You are now equipped with a thorough comparison to guide your purchase.

You understand the core differences in materials, firmness, and ideal sleeper profiles for each model, as well as how Avocado stacks up against its competitors.

The journey to a healthier, more restorative night’s sleep is within your reach.

Your next step is to reflect on your personal sleep habits and preferences.

Are you a side sleeper craving plushness, or a back sleeper in need of firm support?

Does the budget-friendly Eco Organic meet your needs, or is the premium Luxury model calling your name?

Go ahead and choose the organic mattress that aligns with your needs and values.

You’re not just buying a mattress; you’re investing in your well-being and a more sustainable planet.